No. 5 - On Prayers and Alms for the Departed Faithful
By Thine own Blood, O Savior, Thou hast ransomed mortal men, and by Thy death Thou hast delivered us from bitter death, granting us eternal life by Thy Resurrection. Give rest, then, O Lord, to all those who have fallen asleep in godliness, whether in wilderness or city, on the sea or land, in every place, both princes, priests and bishops, monks and married people, of every age and line, and count them worthy of Thy heavenly Kingdom.
(from a Vespers Hymn for the Saturday of Souls)
Why do Orthodox Christians pray and give alms for the dead?
For several reasons!
- This is an uninterrupted practice from the earliest centuries of the Christian Church.
- Death does not destroy the bond between Christians. No! On the contrary, as the Scriptures say, “Love is strong as death.” (Song of Songs 8:6). That is, the bond of agape between Christians overcomes the limits of death. For the Christian, “death is no more.” Therefore, just as we are united by the bond of prayer on earth, so all the more should we unite ourselves by the bond of prayer to those who have gone to the life in the other world.
- We know from the testimony found in the Lives of the Saints and the writings of the Fathers that the prayers and alms of the Church help those who have gone before us.
Do the prayers of the Church really help the departed?
Here is what our Holy Father, St. Nektarios of Aegina (+1920) says about those who have died:
“The Partial Judgment, to which all men are subjected after death, is by no means complete and final, wherefore it naturally follows that they await another, complete and final judgment. During the Partial Judgment, only the soul of man receives its retribution, not the body as well, even though the latter shared with the soul its deeds, good or evil. After the Partial Judgment, the righteous in Heaven and the sinners in Hades have only a foretaste of the blessedness or punishments which they deserve. Finally, after this Partial Judgment some of the sinners will be relieved of the burden of the punishment and will be completely delivered from the sufferings of Hades, not through their own action, but through the prayers of the Church.” (from The Oecumenical Synods of the Church of Christ, by Met. Nektarios [Kephalas], p. 222).
Exactly how our prayers help the departed faithful is unknown to us; it is a mystery of God’s providential care for man that we dare not pry into. But that the prayers of the Church, especially the Divine Liturgy, help the departed, was never questioned by anyone for the first 1500 years of Christian history!
There are numerous examples we can cite from Church history, but here is a very powerful one:
“St. Grigorios Dialogos (St. Gregory the Great) also tells how, in the time of Osios Venediktos (St. Benedict), there were two women who excelled in fasting, but, although they had a reputation for the holiness of their lives, they had an unfortunate passion for talk and used to say much that was untrue and harmful. The saint begged them to restrain their tongues, and, when they disobeyed, he even threatened to excommunicate them. But their passion for lies had taken so deep a root that even threats did not stop them. A few days later they died.
These fasters were buried in a church. When, during the Liturgy, the deacon would say, ‘Catechumens, depart!’ they, since they had been excommunicated, would get out of their tombs and go out. Some pious Christians saw them doing this. When the man of God had been told of this, he sent a prosphoron (altar bread) to the church where the women had been buried and ordered that a part of the bread be taken out for their souls. After this, no one saw them again leaving the church, and the faithful understood that their prayers for the dead women were pleasing to the merciful God, Who then forgave them.” (account found in Dialogue II of St. Gregory the Dialogist [Gregory the Great, Pope of Rome, +604]).
Isn’t this the same as the Roman Catholic teaching about “Purgatory”?
No, it is not, in at least two ways that are essential and significant:
- The Roman Catholic idea of Purgatory is that the departed sinners are cleansed of their sins by their own temporary sufferings in a temporal, cleansing fire after death. In the Orthodox teaching, suffering after death cannot help the departed soul – the time for cleansing sufferings is THIS LIFE, not the next. The departed soul CANNOT HELP ITSELF – only the prayers and alms of those still in this world, that is, the loving sacrifices of members of the CHURCH ON EARTH, can help!
- The teaching on Purgatory is part and parcel of a rationalistic, systematized teaching on merits and indulgences which is foreign to the sweet and mysterious evangelical spirit of Orthodoxy. In Orthodoxy, how prayer and sacrifice help the dead is a profound mystery of God’s mercy to man and the power of man’s love for his fellow man, not a clear-cut system of God’s justice and man’s merits.
How do we pray for the dead?
There are two types of prayer for the dead: public and private.
- Public prayer for the dead consists primarily in the offering of the Divine Liturgy and the Memorial Service.
The Divine Liturgy: At every Divine Liturgy, the Church offers the one Sacrifice of Jesus Christ, which takes away our sins and gives us eternal life. This is an infinite and priceless gift, which Christ has bestowed on us by suffering His terrible passion and death, and rising from the dead on the third day. We can and should frequently give the priest lists of names of our departed faithful to remember at the Proskomidi, when particles of the prosphoron are taken out for the living and the dead. This should always accompany a prosphoron we bake and offer, but we can send lists of the names of the departed into the altar any time.
The Memorial Service is a series of hymns and prayers for the forgiveness and eternal rest of the departed. It may be offered in conjunction with the Divine Liturgy or alone.
The “Kollyva” or “Sitari” is boiled wheat which we bring to the church or cemetery in conjunction with the Divine Liturgy and/or Memorial Service. It is blessed at the service and shared by the faithful afterwards. The wheat is a pledge of the future resurrection of those who have died, recalling the words of Christ recorded in the Gospel according to St. John: “ Amen, amen, I say unto you, Except a grain of wheat fall into the ground and die, it abideth alone: but if it die, it bringeth forth much fruit.” (John 12:24)
Private prayer for the dead consists primarily in reading the Psalms, as well as “saying prayer ropes” and making prostrations with various short prayers.
Reading from the Book of Psalms (the “Psalterion”) is a most ancient and praiseworthy way to pray for the dead. Before we start reading, we simply say, “Remember, O Lord, the soul(s) of Thy departed servants (name or names),” and then we open the book and read. Any of the psalms in any order are fine when reading privately, but Psalms 50, 90, and 118 are especially appropriate in reading for the departed (if you are reading from a Protestant Bible like the King James, these are numbered as Psalms 51, 91, and 119).
Short prayers like the Jesus Prayer or Theotokos and Virgin Rejoice (Prosefhi tou Iisou and Theotoke Parthene) with or without prostrations can be said for the departed. We usually count these on prayer ropes in groups of 100. For example, one can promise that every day for a certain amount of time (like 40 days) one will say 100 Jesus Prayers for the repose of a departed friend or relative
Should we pray for the non-Orthodox who have died?
We certainly should pray for those departed outside the Church, especially our relatives, friends, teachers, and benefactors. The only qualification is that we offer only private prayer for the non-Orthodox, while we offer both private and public prayer for the Orthodox.
If we will stop and think about this for a minute, it makes sense: The non-Orthodox are those who, in this life, never publicly declared or accepted our Faith. We cannot do violence to their religious choices in this life by pretending after their death that they shared our faith. But they may have, in private, been pleasing to God in a way we do not understand, for it has not been revealed to us. Therefore, we pray for them in private.
When should we offer the Divine Liturgy and Memorial for the Orthodox Departed?
We can and should remember the dead at every Divine Liturgy. But it is especially blessed to offer “extra” Liturgies and Memorial Services on SATURDAYS for the departed. This is why:
Saturday, the Seventh Day, is the pre-eminent day for the commemoration of those who have reposed, because it is the day on which the crucified and buried Christ slept in the tomb in the body, while His soul went down to Hades and freed those held captive there. Thus, it is fitting that on this day we remember those whose bodies sleep in the grave and whose souls are either in Paradise or Hades, awaiting the Dread Judgment at the Second Coming of Christ, when the Lord will resurrect the bodies of all men and judge every man according to his works, assigning each one of us his place for all eternity.
By contrast, Sunday, the First Day of the Week, is the Day of the Resurrection, not the day of the sleep in the tomb before the resurrection. Sunday symbolizes eternity, which will begin after the Dread Judgment, when prayers for the dead will no longer be possible, because all will have received their final recompense with no possible change thereafter. This is why the holy canons forbid memorial services on Sunday, which we perform only by oikonomia (“economy” - a bending of the rules for pastoral reasons). On Sunday, no one should weep for the dead but rather should only delight in the foretaste of eternal life.
We do not sin in offering memorials on Sunday, but it is better and more pleasing to God to offer them on Saturday! Yes, it requires extra effort. Yes, it means that our friends and relatives have to give up their Saturday chores, errands and entertainments to come. This is exactly why we should do it. The greater the sacrifice, the greater the grace.
What is the significance of the 3rd Day, 9th Day, and 40th Day after death?
According to Holy Tradition, the soul of the departed person normally remains on earth from the day of death until the third day. From the third day until the ninth day, the angels take the soul and show it the mansions of Paradise and Heaven. From the ninth until the 40th day, the soul is shown hell. On the 40th day, the Lord pronounces a Particular Judgment for this departed person, assigning the soul a place in Paradise or Hades to await the Second Coming, the General Resurrection, and the Dread Judgment.
Thus we should arrange for the Divine Liturgy and Memorial to be served in our parish church on the 3rd, 9th, and 40th day of death for our beloved departed. (The complete funeral and burial service is normally performed on the 3rd day, following the Liturgy). We should also contact monasteries, cathedrals, and other places where the Liturgy is offered daily, and ask that the soul of this person be remembered every day for 40 days. Normally, of course, we send a donation with the name.
It is also important and customary to have the Divine Liturgy and Memorial on the 6th month and one year anniversaries of death, as well as on or near the anniversary of death every year thereafter. These anniversary services are normally performed on the Saturday nearest the actual date.
How do we give alms on behalf of the departed?
We can give large or small donations on behalf of the departed to churches, monasteries, charitable institutions, and needy individuals. When making the gift, always write a note saying, “Please pray for the soul of _______________, in whose memory this gift is made.” Sacrifice on behalf of the departed is very important – it is prayer in action, active love, which is very pleasing to Our Lord.
We have these testimonies to the power of alms from the Lives of the Saints:
From the Life of the Holy Monk Luke (“Osios Loukas”):
“...the blessed monk Luke had a brother who became a monk but took little care of his own soul. Death came upon him in a state of carelessness. Blessed Luke was distressed that his brother had not prepared properly for death. He therefore prayed God to reveal to him his brother’s destiny. Thereupon the old man saw his brother’s soul in the power of evil spirits. Immediately after this vision he sent some men to inspect his brother’s cell. They found there money and some other things. Luke then understood that his brother’s soul was suffering for breaking the vow of poverty, as well as for other sins. He took everything that had been found and gave it away to beggars for the sake of his brother’s salvation.
Sometime later, when the blessed Luke was at prayer, he had another revelation. He saw a judgment seat at which the angels of light were disputing with the evil spirits over the possession of the dead monk’s soul. Luke heard the evil spirits cry out: ‘This soul is ours, for it used to do deeds inspired by us!’ But the angels said to them that the soul was saved from their power because of the alms that had been given for its sake. The evil spirits retorted: ‘Did the dead man himself give alms? Was it not the old monk who did so?’ and they pointed at the blessed Luke. Luke said, ‘Yes, it was I who gave alms, but I did not do so for my own sake but for the sake of this soul.’ The evil spirits, put to shame by the monk’s reply, dispersed. Luke, however, was put at ease by his vision and ceased mourning his brother’s lot.”
From the Life of the Holy Abbess Athanasia:
Are there some good books in which I can learn more about life after death?
“The Higoumena Athanasia told the sisters of her monastery that after her death they should for her sake feed beggars for forty days. But when she died, the sisters invited beggars for ten days only, and after that were too lazy to obey their Gerondissa! But the matter did not rest here. Athanasia appeared to the sisters and said: ‘Let everyone know that alms given for a departed soul during the forty days after death, as well as food offered to the hungry, are pleasing to God. If the departed souls are sinful, they thus are pardoned by God; if they are righteous, the good deeds thus performed serve to save the souls of the survivors who perform them.’ ” (Lives of the Saints)
Certainly. You can start with these:
Life after Death, by Hierotheos (Vlachos), Metropolitan of Nafpaktos
The Soul after Death, by Hieromonk Seraphim (Rose)
We will be happy to order these titles through our church bookstore for everyone who is interested!
Brothers and sisters! Think upon our own sinful lives. Will we die in true repentance, cleansed of all our sins? Are we so sure that we deserve Paradise? Is it not true that, after death, we may very well need someone to pray for us? Let us, then frequently offer sacred Liturgies and Memorials, as well as give donations to the Church and alms to the needy for the sake of the dead, so that, when we die, someone will do this for us:
Blessed are the merciful, for they shall obtain mercy!